Bennie the Birthday Bug is an insect that visits Elisha McLaughlin on every birthday, bringing with him presents and gifts. No one knows where he comes from or why he's green. He doesn't visit Zack Rearick because, hey, one bug can't do everything, right? He gave the two Seers the third Magic Word, as well as the boxset of the complete series of How I Met Your Mother as Elisha's early 21st birthday present.